Casa Nonna

I have been visiting the Turks for 16 years, and owned property there for 12. I recently had one of the top 2 lobster dishes ever at Casa Nonna. The Lobster Ravioli was phenomenal. We were fortunate to speak with Mimi, the gifted chef that brought this recipe here. She shared one of her secrets, which I promised not to disclose. The preparation made for the most tender, umami lobster ever. The raviolis were loaded with lobster, and there was an entire lobster tail with white wine sauce as well. Mimi and the manager Mary made us feel very welcome, after recovering from hurricane Oscar. We will definitely return there.

This had to be the best dining experience we had on the island. The food was delicious and the ambiance was fantastic. The live jazz player was a phenomenal artist and really enhanced our dining experience.

We had a great meal here. The staff was very welcoming and accommodating to our party. Our server, Wood, even went so far as to sing happy birthday while balancing a dessert on his head with a live saxophone accompaniment. The food was great. Several members of our group said their meals were some of the best versions of the dishes they've had. Some noteworthy dishes were the butternut squash ravioli, meatballs, fried calamari, and crispy foccacia. It's also worth noting that the restaurant has a spacious set up with tables placed so that you're not dining on top of your neighbors.

Our very last night on the island, we ate dinner at Casa Nonna and it was by far the best meal we had the entire trip! Truly great Italian food, the spaghetti was amazing! We were celebrating my Mom's birthday, our waitress was very sweet, brought over a dessert and sang. She was professional throughout the evening and truly took her job very serious. If we are ever back on the island, we would absolutely have another meal here.

Beautiful restaurant with fine food but it is all a facade. Go visit this place if you have 4 hours of free time and like room temp food. They were understaffed and it SHOWED. However, we did notice workers standing around while our server drowned. I will say.. the meatballs were delicious. After we had such an amazing experience on the sunset cruise, this place completely destroyed the vibe. We were not the only ones with issues either. There was another party that walked up to a server by our table and told them they were ready to order drinks, so they had to wait so long they had to find a server and asked to order. Our server completely disappeared at one point. Just a terrible experience for us. Casa Nonna is a Casa No No for us. Never again.